Back to How-To

How-To

Ask a Pro: Do I Want a Low Hiking Shoe or Mid Hiking Boot?

Seth Quigg | Oboz Ambassador

Back to How-To

Welcome to our fourth installation of Ask a Pro, where guides from Wildland Trekking, offer professional advice for life on the trail.   

What shoes do I wear in the mountains? This is a common question from our clients at Wildland Trekking, and it’s also a popular debate among hikers. 

Ultimately there is no right answer as to which is a better choice for hiking. There are a lot of considerations when picking your trail footwear. Here’s what I like along with tips I recommend so my friends and clients may find their ideal boot or shoe.

Personal Preference

These days, as a 37-year-old, part time trekking and mountain guide, I mainly choose a low-cut, lightweight hiking shoe like the Sawtooth II. But that wasn’t always the case.

When I was in my teens and 20’s, I went hard! I challenged myself a lot in the mountains and got hurt and injured often. Back then I would carry 50-60 lb. backpacks for 30-45 days at a time and I strained and sprained my ankles numerous times before one of my mentors told me, “Whatever you do, be gentle and deliberate on your body when you are in the mountains.  Go slow, to go fast.”

During that time, I wore high-cut, leather boots that provided a lot of support when carrying a heavy pack. Most everyone did.

Pros and Cons of Mid-Hikers

Here are some pros, cons and environmental considerations for choosing a high-cut boot.

PROS

  • More support on your ankles when carrying a heavy pack
  • More protection from the elements. i.e. rocks, snow, shrubbery, etc.
  • Appropriate for novices or in-experienced mountain travelers

When might you want a taller, more supportive boot?

  • Larger expeditions or Backpacking trips where you may need more foot support.
  • Colder, rainier, muddier, snowier locations such as Alaska, Patagonia, etc.
  • Environments where there are NO trails and you will be bushwhacking
  • If you are partaking in technical activities and need crampon or ski adaptability.

CONS

They are heavier than low cut shoes and can feel clunky.

They restrict mobility making travel inefficient and slower.

When NOT to wear a mid boot?

  • Locations where you will be hiking on trails; I do not think you need a high-cut boot if you will be solely walking on trails.
  • Lighter and allow you to move more efficiently
  • I have the ability to flex my ankles and the rigidity of High-cut boot makes me more prone to injure again.

Pros and Cons of Low Hiking Shoes

Nowadays, I know my backcountry systems better and what I ‘need’ to carry; as a result, my packing is much more efficient and lighter. Because I have past weak ankles from past injuries, wearing a low-cut shoe enables my ankles to flex more and improves my balance.

Additionally, I go with the low-cut more frequently for weight savings. 

Pros and Cons of a Low Hiking Shoe

PROS

When might you want a low hiking shoe?

  • Trails, Trails, Trails!!!
  • Carrying less weight (day packs, 20-30 lb. backpacks); Overnights
  • Dry climates such as the desert, summer in the Rocky Mountains, etc.

CONS

  • Less support
  • Feet can get cold easier if you have adverse weather

When should you NOT wear a low hiker?

  • Locations that have adverse weather.
  • Hiking off trail
  • Large backpacking trips

ADDITIONAL CONSIDERATIONS

Another thing to consider is boot and shoe fit and the tread of the shoe. You want your boots/shoes to be comfortable, but in order to maximize their comfort you need to use them.

There is a sweet spot between 3 and 15 trips (3-10 days in the mountains) where the shoes are performing best. Initially they will be rigid and new. You need to break them in. 

Finally, I do not recommend wearing running shoes as they do not perform well in muddy and slippery environments. I know from past experience. 

BOTTOM LINE

There are certainly pros and cons to both, low and high-cut shoes. I encourage everyone to experiment with both types of shoes and to figure out which type you prefer and for what environment. It is always good to mix it up and try different boots to fit your unique foot and style of mountain travel.

Seth Quigg is a hiking and backpacking guide for the Wildland Trekking Company.

 

Seth Quigg

Name: Seth Quigg

Hometown: Crested Butte, Colo.

Where I’ve Been: The best hike I ever did was 28 days trek in the Ngorongoro Conservation area in Tanzania, and I've been fortunate to hike all over the world.

Why I Hike: Adventure. I have worked on the islands of Borneo and Madagascar.  Lead over 10 expeditions in the Himalaya.

Lead The Way: As a co-founder of Wildland Trekking, I aim to bring more people into the outside world. 

Ambassador Focus: #protip

Find Me:

Instagram: @wildlandtrekking

Men's Sawtooth II Low
MSRP $110.00
Compare

Similar posts

Comments